10 Pizza Spots on Anna Maria Island: Your Ultimate Guide to the Best Pizza on AMI
"Who has the best pizza?" It’s a question we hear time and time again from locals and visitors alike. AMI isn't just known for its sun-drenched beaches and tranquil waters—it also offers a fantastic selection of pizzerias that are sure to satisfy any pizza craving. Whether you're relaxing after a day in the sun or simply seeking a delicious and casual meal, the island's diverse pizza spots offer everything from wood-fired creations to family-friendly favorites. Here’s your ultimate guide to the top 10 pizza places on Anna Maria Island, each with its own unique flavor and charm.
Pizza Social
📍 308 Pine Ave, Anna Maria, FL
📞 (941) 251-4070
⏰ Daily: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM; Tuesday: CLOSED
Pizza Social is a local favorite that’s renowned for its hand-crafted pizzas and fresh salads. The secret lies in their handmade dough which makes every slice a treat. The imported Italian pizza oven ensures a perfectly baked pie every time. If you're looking for something special, don’t miss their garlic Parmesan nuggets—they're a must-try! Pizza Social also caters to gluten-free diets, making it a versatile choice for everyone. While the pizza might take a bit longer to prepare, the wait is well worth it for a perfectly crafted pizza.
The Feast Restaurant
📍 5406 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach, FL
📞 (941) 778-5092
⏰ Daily: 3:30 PM - 9:00 PM
The Feast offers a mix of modern Italian cuisine and rustic gourmet pizza. This casual fine dining restaurant offers many dishes, from seafood and steak to pasta and decadent desserts. The pizza here is a standout and has long been a favorite of locals and visitors. However, a change has been made recently and their popular wood-fired pizzas are available for take-out only, so be sure to keep this in mind!
Vinny's Italian Kitchen
📍 AMI Plaza, 5337 Gulf Dr, Suite 500, Holmes Beach, FL
📞 (941) 896-9754
⏰ Tuesday-Saturday: 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM; Sunday-Monday: CLOSED
For an authentic Italian experience, Vinny’s Italian Kitchen is a must-visit. Located close to both Anna Maria and Holmes Beach, this restaurant serves thin-crust pizzas in traditional Italian style. If you’re craving a hearty meal at home, Vinny’s also provides carry-out options. Be sure to explore their on-site market and Italian deli for a true taste of Italy.
Solo’s Pizza
📍 3244 East Bay Drive, Holmes Beach, FL
📞 (941) 778-8118
⏰ Sunday, Monday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday: 5:00 PM - 9:00 PM; Saturday: 12:00 PM - 9:00 PM; Tuesday: CLOSED
Solo’s Pizza is the perfect place for a casual, fun dining experience. Known for its fresh pizzas, burgers, and subs, Solo’s also features a pool table and a laid-back atmosphere. It’s an excellent spot to hang out with friends or family, offering great deals and both dine-in and carry-out options. Selective hours so be sure to make sure they are open!
Wilder’s Slice of AMI
📍 103 Gulf Dr N, Bradenton Beach, FL
📞 (941) 900-1584
⏰ Sunday-Thursday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM; Friday-Saturday: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wilder’s Slice of AMI is a fantastic addition to Bradenton Beach, offering both NY-style thin crust and Sicilian-style slices. With a focus on fresh ingredients and simple, tasty pies, Wilder’s caters to various tastes. The relaxed atmosphere makes it a great place to grab a slice while enjoying the island’s laid-back vibe.
Pizzano’s Pizza and Grinderz
📍 5318 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach, FL
📞 (941) 778-3663
⏰ Monday-Thursday: 10:00 AM - Midnight; Friday-Saturday: 10:00 AM - 1:00 AM; Sunday: 11:00 AM - Midnight
Pizzano’s Pizza is known for its robust flavors and family-friendly atmosphere. Their menu features both classic and creative pizzas, making it a great choice for a satisfying meal. You can order online for fast delivery. Plus, Pizzano’s is open late at night, so it's perfect for a late dinner or an after-hours pizza craving.
Slim's Place
📍 9701 Gulf Drive, Anna Maria, FL
📞 (941) 567-4056
⏰ Daily: 11:30 AM - 10:00 PM; MONDAY: 3:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Voted the top sports bar on Anna Maria Island, Slim’s Place combines a fantastic sports atmosphere with delicious food. Known for its Philly cheesesteaks, this spot also serves up thin-crust pizzas. It’s the ideal place for a casual meal while catching the big game.
Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant
📍 201 Gulf Drive, Bradenton Beach, FL
📞 (941) 778-0771
⏰ Wednesday-Sunday: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM; Monday-Tuesday: CLOSED
Oma’s Pizza and Italian Restaurant is a top pick for both pizza and Italian dishes. Their Sicilian Oma Special is a fan favorite, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and black olives. The restaurant also offers delicious calzones and tempting desserts like tiramisu and chocolate-dipped cannoli. With its late hours and quick delivery service, Oma’s is perfect for a late-night pizza craving or a cozy night in.
Danny’s Pizzeria
📍 7220 Manatee Ave W, Bradenton, FL
📞 (941) 795-1111
⏰ Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM; Friday-Saturday: 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM; Sunday: 12:00 PM - 8:00 PM; Monday: CLOSED
Just a short drive over the bridge to West Bradenton, Danny’s Pizzeria brings a taste of New York-style pizza to the island. Known for its classic pizza slices and hearty dinner options like chicken parmigiana and sausage and peppers, Danny’s offers great food at reasonable prices. Don’t miss their taco pizza—an adventurous twist that’s sure to delight.
Domino’s Pizza
📍 5606 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach, FL
📞 (941) 778-6641
⏰ Sunday-Thursday: 10:30 AM - Midnight; Friday-Saturday: 10:30 AM - 1:00 AM
Sometimes, after a long day of beach fun, you just want to relax at your vacation rental and enjoy a familiar meal. Domino’s Pizza offers fast delivery and a wide range of pizza options, making it a convenient choice for a cozy night in. It’s a reliable option when you’re craving classic pizza comfort without the need to venture out.
Since everyone has their own opinion on what makes the best pizza, we’ll let you decide! Try them all and see which one you think reigns supreme. Enjoy your pizza adventure on Anna Maria Island and savor every delicious bite!
Comments